Lack
of Workers Increases Vulnerability to Attack
This article was published in the
Central Penn Business Journal, November 2, 2001
Ira S. Wolfe
Guest Columnist
Founder, Success Performance Solutions
The
attacks on America couldn't have come at a worse time for healthcare.
Since
September 11 the threat of biological and chemical terrorism has put our
entire country on high alert. It is no longer unthinkable that a biological
or chemical attack could infect thousands and expose hundreds of thousands
simultaneously in multiple locations.
It's
also no secret that the scarcity of health care workers was getting worse
over the past few years and these labor shortages were showing no signs of
going away. Now with the real threat of bio-terrorism, many positions on
the front lines of health care are unfilled and back-ups are virtually
non-existent. As is the case with antibiotic and vaccine supplies, our
health care system is short workers. Unlike antibiotics and vaccines,
workers cannot be manufactured, trained, or replaced as easily or quickly.
Government
and public health officials do not exude confidence when they speak about
our ability to respond to a large, unannounced attack. Tommy Thompson,
Secretary of Health and Human Services, in early October reported, "we
have not been aggressive enough in preparing our country for
bio-terrorism". A few days earlier Mohammad Akhter, Executive Director
of the American Public Health Association, warned, "when it comes to a
larger (biological) attack, then we are not prepared."
Mr.
Akther then cited, or more appropriately indicted, our national and state
health departments. The reality is that approximately ten percent of the
health departments in the United States do not even have e-mail. If a
bio-terrorist attack occurred on a Friday afternoon, Akhter reported to
Congress, there would be no report of it until Monday morning under the
current staffing profile of most health departments. Patients could be
showing up in hospitals and doctors offices days before our health care
providers have been notified of an exposure.
These
public statements, like many others during recent weeks, intended to ease
public fears have been focused on the identification of the biological
agent, isolation of the exposure, and the availability of vaccines and
antibiotics. Little attention, at least publicly, is being given to the
growing need for more and more health care workers, while the incumbent
workforce is increasingly dissatisfied with their jobs and leaving the
profession at an alarming rate.
In
the event of a bio-terrorist attack, emergency rooms will be inundated
under an avalanche of infected or exposed people requiring treatment and
healthy people demanding preventive medicines. As a result, there would be
a surge in need for trained personnel who can diagnose and treat rare
diseases, and also for isolation areas and rapid mobilization of special
drugs and vaccines.
Even
before the attacks, hospitals could barely address the volume of patients
on an emergent basis. Reports of ambulances arriving at emergency rooms
only to be diverted away due to overcrowding, and floors of hospitals being
closed due to understaffing were becoming commonplace news since the late
1990' and past year.
But
even if emergency rooms and health departments are optimized to handle the
crush of people, there may be nowhere for infected or injured patients to
go. Many hospitals are already frustrated by employee vacancies that exceed
20% and turnover rates are even higher. In a June 2001 American Hospital
Association survey hospitals reported average vacancies of 9 percent in
housekeeping and 11 percent for registered nurses.
Vacancies
for laboratory technicians, who will be required to draw blood and analyze
the results, were averaging 12 percent. The results of a 2001 Clinical
Laboratory Management Association member survey showed that 64 percent of
respondents did not have enough qualified personnel to staff their workload
and 89 percent reported the number of new graduates in their region was
insufficient.
Competing
for top honors in the number of budgeted but unfilled positions are
radiological technologists at 18 percent and pharmacists, who will be
needed to prescribe the antidotes, antibiotics, and medicines, at 21
percent.
Shortages
do not stop here but go right to the very top of hospitals. Industry
analysts estimate there exists a 40% gap between the supply of healthcare
executives talent pool and the demand for candidates to fill new positions
and replace retiring leaders.
We're
also approaching the winter season, a time when emergency rooms are
normally filled to capacity with patients presenting with common
respiratory infections and broken bones. Compound all of this with the
financial implications of providing care to an increasing pool of uninsured
due to recent layoffs, and our strained health care system is bending very
close to its stress point.
An
appropriate and adequate response for recruitment, retention and training
efforts will require a lot of money and funding. But a key consequence of
the Sept. 11 attacks has been the continued downturn in the stock market,
which has drastically reduced non-operating revenue. Any deterioration of
non-operating revenue directly reduces the hospitals' debt service
coverage, 60% of which is produced from non-operating revenue, according to
Fitch, the international bond rating agency.
So
faced with understaffing, under-preparedness, and under-funding, our
healthcare system is on the brink of attack while it is being called upon
to defend us against what may be the largest scale hostile act on the
American people in our history.
During
this past summer and before September 11 Mary Anne Kelly, executive
director of the American Society for Healthcare Human Resources
Administration, acknowledged that "we have our work cut out for
us", referring to the efforts her organization would need to make to
win the war for talent. Her comments now appear to be a gross
understatement of the situation.
Dr.
Ira S. Wolfe is founder of Success Performance Solutions and President of
Poised for the Future Company. Success Performance Solutions is a
consulting firm, based in Leola, PA, specializing in matching, managing,
motivating and retaining employees in many industries including healthcare
extending from Pennsylvania to Hong Kong.
|